Paper Title:
Authors:
Summary of Content of Paper:
A: Quality of the Research
| Item | My comments |
|---|---|
|
1. Is the research question or objective clearly stated? |
|
|
2. Is the research question interesting and important? |
|
|
3. Is the work original? |
|
|
4. Is the background research clear and relevant? |
|
|
5. Are there any ethical problems? |
|
B: The Research Method
| Item | My comments |
|---|---|
|
Summarise the research method |
|
|
Does the research method seem appropriate for the research question? |
|
|
Are the methods adequately described? |
|
|
Were the analyses done correctly? |
|
|
Are the conclusions supported by the data? |
|
C: Quality of Presentation
| Item | My comments |
|---|---|
|
Is the work well presented? |
|
|
Is the paper well structured? |
|
|
Are symbols, terms, and concepts adequately defined? |
|
|
Would additional tables, figures help to clarify the work? |
|
D: Additional Notes
| Item | My comments |
|---|---|
|
Use this section to record additional notes on the paper. In particular you should identify any links to other topics and papers from the module |
|